Did we see a Classic winner at the Craven meeting or should we focus on those who skipped it?
An informative week at Newmarket saw Amo Racing duo Mammas Girl and Indestructible gallop to glory in the two Guineas trials – but were our experts impressed?
Two gallopers have excellent chances in 2,000 Guineas
I wouldn’t think either of the horses who won the main Guineas trials – Mammas Girl and Indestructible – will be winning the Classics. If Girl Racer turned up in the Qipco 1,000 Guineas (she needs to be supplemented) I’d be interested in her as she had no luck at a key point in the Nell Gwyn.
Canberra Legend emerged as a bit of a dark horse for the Betfred Derby when winning the Feilden Stakes, so I’d keep an eye on him.
However, the best Classic prospects were those who galloped at the Rowley Mile rather than raced at the course. Sakheer and Silver Knott are two horses I think have excellent chances in the Qipco 2,000 Guineas next month.
Peter Scargill, deputy industry editor
Mammas most impressive of Amo trial winners
Chaldean was my idea of the 2,000 Guineas winner prior to this week and Indestructible boosted that form from last season with a convincing Craven win.
I would still side with last year’s Dewhurst winner, and we’ll learn more about him in the Greenham on Saturday, but Indestructible certainly enters each-way equations. He was put in his place by Chaldean on unsuitable soft ground in the Champagne but there was only half a length to split them in the Acomb last year and a course-and-distance win only boosts his claims.
If we did see a Guineas winner at the Craven meeting, it is more likely to be Mammas Girl. I was really impressed with how she finished her race in the Nell Gwyn and she is 2-2 on the Rowley Mile. Her Racing Post Rating was 1lb shy of last year’s scorer Cachet, who went on to land the 1,000 Guineas.
Jack Haynes, reporter
Nothing to put me off Royal Scotsman
I would have no doubt both Amo Racing-owned horses Indestructible and Mammas Girl will run bold races in the 2,000 and 1,000 Guineas, with the latter holding stronger claims in what may be a slightly weaker contest.
Indestructible's win in the Craven enhanced the form of Chaldean significantly, having been comfortably beaten by Juddmonte's colt twice in Group company at York and Doncaster before his season-defining win in the Dewhurst Stakes.
It is the Dewhurst form I remain most confident about in finding the 2,000 Guineas winner, but with the runner-up Royal Scotsman.
He flew home to be beaten only a short-head and would have won with another 100 yards. He's by 2015 2,000 Guineas winner Gleneagles, so should relish the step up to a mile.
Matt Rennie, reporter
Read more . . .
'He's very exciting' - Amo's dream week continues as Indestructible flies into 2,000 Guineas picture
Subscribe today | Get 50% off your first three months
Do you want £200+ of free bets? Racing Post have got the best offers, all in one place. Visit racingpost.com/freebets to find out more.
Published on inExpert jury
Last updated
- How do you see next year's Classics following the Futurity Trophy at Doncaster?
- 'It would be foolish to think it was a pure fluke' - what did our experts make of Anmaat's Champion Stakes win?
- 'Everything went wrong and he still won' - find out which juveniles impressed our experts most at Newmarket
- 'The 7-2 could look massive after the Fillies' Mile' - our experts have their say on next year's Classics
- 'Odds of 12-1 are too big' - our experts have their say on an open Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe
- How do you see next year's Classics following the Futurity Trophy at Doncaster?
- 'It would be foolish to think it was a pure fluke' - what did our experts make of Anmaat's Champion Stakes win?
- 'Everything went wrong and he still won' - find out which juveniles impressed our experts most at Newmarket
- 'The 7-2 could look massive after the Fillies' Mile' - our experts have their say on next year's Classics
- 'Odds of 12-1 are too big' - our experts have their say on an open Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe